Jump to content

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

lokey

Apple Watch 2 (AW2) with Nike+

Recommended Posts

Hi Guys,

Just wanna write a review of the Apple Watch 2 (Nike+ Series), for the benefit of those who are about to fork out $500 for the device. X'mas season right? read this before you do. I got it a week ago. After being seduced by slick Ads and the "sexy" look of the watch, waterproof and all, i finally succumbed and bought it. Well it didn't really work straight out of the box. For 3 days I struggled to get it to work. Did all the research on the internet. Set all the settings. The native running app worked. MapMyRun (MMR) worked. But NRC+ app did not track. I thought I needed to bring the iPhone along. Well the iPhone NRC+ worked... by itself. The watch did not track. It kept telling "your distance is not tracked please yada yada yada. Scratching my head...it was a WTF moment! $500! WTF!. Then I figured it out. Uninstall and Reinstall everything. https://discussions.apple.com/message/31141070#message31141070. It finally worked.

Here's my review of it. I ran with AW2 on my left and Garmin 235 on my right hand. Clocked 8.45km.

1. Start/Stop - AW2 Nike+ app - Auto 3,2,1 Start or 9 seconds start and Just Start. It does not show GPS signals strength. Or if you are locked. Once you start running without a satellite lock you lose the first km of your run. Need a fix there. You see, you need the first stable set of GPS signal data and the rest is calculated relative to the last signal, thats how you get location, speed and direction. (Btw you need to acquire 4 satellite GPS pings before it is accurate). 

2. Screen and HUDisplay (NRC+ app) - Very "sexy". Great colors. Big Fonts. 5 stars there. But it shows up only on wrist turns. HR bpm is very small on top left. 
The Bad - screen cannot be customized. Only rotate between Dist, Time(Duration) and Pace. No Speed, no Last Lap. Screen is NOT customizable.
As for the rest of the native app and MMR, not so nice interface but functional.

3. GPS Tracking - the AW2 performed almost the same as the FR235. Tracking in open areas was better, while next to buildings, the lines then to swing. This is fine, given the GPS signal blockage. AW2 tracked 8.45km while the FR235 tracked 8.38km.

4. HR monitoring - this is where the difference is. AW2 measured my peak at 168bpm. While at the same time FR235 measured 155bpm. Started almost the same but as the rate increased, AW2 showed 5% faster.

5. Other accessory metrics - The AW2 does not have the HRM option. No Footpod. Only relies on the native GPS of the watch.

6. Strap - Very unconventional to put on. Very afraid to slip and drop the AW2.

In short, IMHO the serious runners will be disappointed with this watch. A lot of potential but they made it too simple. And it seems that Nike+ launched this in a hurry. Maybe it will get better in a few months. I will stick to my FR235 and FX3HR. Going to take it for a final test. Running on a threadmill. 

Happy Holidays and Safe Running to All.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Looks like the AW2 is more for leisure runners who wants distance and pace to be stated... HR is additional "bonus" thus being slightly inaccurate might be fine for them... Great review !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi It's me again,

Just did a 5K Indoor. Nike+ can connect with Garmin Connect.... hmmm good.
1. Left hand - Apple Watch only
2. Right hand - FR235 + Chest HR + Footpod.
I take it that the FR gives the closer readings. (calibrated it on a stadium track)
Distance about 360m off. 5-6%.
The red line is the HR readings. Almost the same.
Pace green line - the FR235 w footpod tracks it more distinctly, while the AW2 graph is flatter.

I know, who really cares about all these right?... look nice Ok already. Wrong. If I am going to pay $500 for AW2, they better get it right, just like the iPhone.
 

applewatch2_nike.jpg

fr253.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Lokey for your simpler version of a DC Rainmaker review of the Apple Watch 2 (Nike+ Series) :D

If the difference is 5 to 6%, that is quite unacceptable by standard. So this AW2 still has lots of improvement and hope it has software & firmware updates like Garmin GPS watches to further improve features and interfaces, or else it is a big pity for AW2.

Sidetrack a bit, I was looking at DC Rainmaker testing of sport devices GPS accuracy  (part 1 review at https://www.dcrainmaker.com/2010/11/sport-device-gps-accuracy-in-depth-part.html  & part 2: https://www.dcrainmaker.com/2010/11/sport-device-gps-accuracy-in-depth-part_11.html )

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The difference in distance translate to a difference in pace... a pace of 7:06 vs 6:38 is too much of a difference... imagine a 5hr marathon vs 4hr 40mins finishing time...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



  • Upcoming Events

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • AutumnRunner must have just come out of deep hiatus as can see his post is now everywhere. This year's Craze Ultra, no more 100 miles! Also, Simonleng is the first one to register and has gotten the BIB #1. So surely you can expect to see him there.  May be to satisfy everyone once and for all, who's eager to see you take part in Craze Ultra, you can consider joining the new 27km category. 😂
    • Looks like they can't decide which is which. https://s.tgr.run/overview/ - It says ROAD here.
    • Lol. You looked too fast.  It's TGR brings to Singapore a hybrid trail/road marathon, half marathon and 10km!
    • This must be a record breaking feat as we already can register for a run that is more than 1 year from now.   YES 1 YEAR AHEAD. And the best part is? You can pull out your registration ANYTIME and they will refund you 100% of what you paid!  The only catch, besides the deadline of 31 July for registering this to enjoy this offer, is the ridiculous prices. It is probably the highest fees I have seen so far for a competitive run, and I already think that despite the good reviews for this year's run that happened just last Sunday, the high costs really do not justify what you will get for the race and entitlements, no matter how good it is. Yes the fees also cover a HK TGR run, but how many of us really do fly out to HK and enjoy the race slot that is included in the race fees? That said, this is actually a good marketing ploy to get more registration fees. I am guessing the average actual cost incurred per runner is likely to be less than half of the fees (Meaning they don't incur more than $30 cost for a 10km run, $40 for a 21km run and $50 for a 42km run. The resources are shared anyway.), so even if you turn up for both the runs, which is not very likely, they will earn profits anyway. Limited S.TGR Marathon RSVP Registration - 20 Jun 2020 RSVP register for S.TGR 2020 now to receive full entitlements and one free entry to any similar distance GreenRace in Hong Kong. This limited offer will expire on 31 July. 

      Reserve your bib now for S.TGR 2020 and receive these benefits: 
      - One Free Entry to any to any similar distance GreenRace in Hong Kong
      - 100% ‘refundable anytime’ race entry if your SG+HK TGR entries remain unused
      - Special Edition Sustainably Sourced Finisher Award
      - Special Edition S.TGR Singlet by Uglow(TM)
      - GreenRace Speed Cup by Hydrapak(TM)
      - GreenRace Running Bib/Belt
      - Free bib transfer/upgrade/downgrades 

      Fine Print
      - Final S.TGR event date may change and is subject to government and local permit approvals. 
      - 100% refund is available for RSVP Registration only (all other TGR registrations are non-refundable). 
      - Both SG and HK TGR events must remain unused in order to receive any refund. 
      - This limited offer will expire on 31 July. 

      Registration Fees
      - 10K SG$60
      - 21K SG$80
      - 42K SG$100  
    • Yes price is the main thing that deters me from signing up. Is it not meant to be a trail run in the first place? I understand the HK ones they organize are trail runs, but I am not sure if that is the case for Singapore. When I look at their website it says:
      TGR brings to Singapore a road marathon, half marathon and 10km! 
×