Jump to content

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

trailblazer

New Release of Garmin GPS Running Watch: Forerunner 220 & 620

Recommended Posts

Anyone 620 users having accuracy issues?

I have done 2 runs so far on firmware 2.8 (GPS 3.1): 10km (actual distance ~10.7km) and 2.27km (actual 2.4km), course is 730m lap on mapometer (http://sg.mapometer.com/running/route_2573418.html), tree cover is like any normal neighbourhood.

From above, the error margin is ~7% and 5.42%... which is quite substantial in my opinion. Is this the norm for most GPS watches considering the tree cover?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Do you have the GPS track to compare?

You can try to submit report to garmin either e-mailing (forgot the exact email) or go on forum to post.

https://forums.garmin.com/forum.php

One of the hotter FR620 threads

https://forums.garmin.com/showthread.php?65707-GPS-inaccuracies/page28

GPS tracks here:

http://connect.garmin.com/activity/528253631

http://connect.garmin.com/activity/530918044

I'll post in that topic then, seems to be quite a common issue for this model.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

assuming you are lapping the same route.. dear god... those are ugly...

Had same issue with my Fenix2.. qq..

Although I think software wise the fenix and FR team are different working groups.

Ya.. I noticed the gps tracking become really bad near thick foliage/ tall buildings...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Agree with lazyitachi. Your 620 really didn't plot the route you took well.

For my 220,I don't really have such issue but in the worst case situation it fails, I may want to use it with a calibrated footpod (back up move).

Puzzling to see a high end 620 will have off tangent route plotting issue. Hmm...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I relook at the track and I switch to satellite mode to see actual terrain.

All I see is tall building... tall building.. tall buildings....

I can only tell you from running in CBD... somehow the gps is REALLY skewed by tall buildings...

I walk even 50 m near.. the track go haywire.. HAIZ...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So... apparently it's the highrise + tree cover and also 620 doesn't do well with lapping. I'm aware of the limitations of GPS watches but a 620 giving this margin of error is quite unacceptable given that it's quite high-end.

http://fellrnr.com/wiki/Best_Running_Watch

http://fellrnr.com/wiki/GPS_Accuracy

This guy plots data from a lot of watches and it seems that using a calibrated footpod is the best option. And apparently the GPS in the iPhone 4s is really really good :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So... apparently it's the highrise + tree cover and also 620 doesn't do well with lapping. I'm aware of the limitations of GPS watches but a 620 giving this margin of error is quite unacceptable given that it's quite high-end.

http://fellrnr.com/wiki/Best_Running_Watch

http://fellrnr.com/wiki/GPS_Accuracy

This guy plots data from a lot of watches and it seems that using a calibrated footpod is the best option. And apparently the GPS in the iPhone 4s is really really good :P

wow. quite informative, thanks for sharing. And I am also using a 620. :(

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So... apparently it's the highrise + tree cover and also 620 doesn't do well with lapping. I'm aware of the limitations of GPS watches but a 620 giving this margin of error is quite unacceptable given that it's quite high-end.

http://fellrnr.com/wiki/Best_Running_Watch

http://fellrnr.com/wiki/GPS_Accuracy

This guy plots data from a lot of watches and it seems that using a calibrated footpod is the best option. And apparently the GPS in the iPhone 4s is really really good :P

wow. quite informative, thanks for sharing. And I am also using a 620. :(

No problem.

Anyway I have done some research on foot pods too. The main advantage is once you calibrate them, they are more accurate than GPS for distance, pace and cadence. The main catch is with change in speed/pace, change in shoes, change in location placed on shoes, the calibration will be off (which is quite a pain in the ass IMO). So for me, the only real reason to use foot pods is for treadmill running because when running outdoors, I will probably be changing shoes and changing pace pretty often.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Going for IPPT soon and would like to know if the timing works fine without GPS and function like a stopwatch?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Going for IPPT soon and would like to know if the timing works fine without GPS and function like a stopwatch?

Yes,you can use the your Garmin Forerunner 220/620 without the GPS. It can only track time if you do so but even having said that,I will switch on the GPS function if my IPPT run has a stadium track.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Does the 620 have an internal accelerometer?

Cos Fenix 2 has one and it uses your recorded stride length to guesstimate your pace (based on your cadence) and okok accuracy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yes..... in fact both 220 and 620 have an on-board accelerometer that is pre-calibrated so even with no gps signals, we would still be able to track our cadence.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Have you guys tried the HRM with other running apps on your iPhone or Android? Cos I'm testing with my friend and he's interested to purchase the Garmin HRM to pair with his iPhone/Android and use it with Adidas MiCoach App. I have tried to pair with my Samsung S5 but it doesn't detect the HRM.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Does anyone know where to buy the HRM-run and how much it cost? Mine start to split...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I bought mine online.... its unboxed from ebay...

but it works for me..... fingers crossed nth happen within the year...

else... have to think of ways to game the system...

The local distros i think is quite expensive IIRC .. 150 SGD?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



  • Upcoming Events

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Why WMM over IAAF? Think you'll find that is down to how WMM markets and promotes those cities that are in this exclusive club. Especially with medal chasers. Look at who is in this exclusive club....2 major financial hubs, and with Brexit - perhaps Berlin is set to be a financial hub. Assume being part of the WMM will also come with a fee. So between IAAF and WMM, the STPB would find WMM more attractive and this would give Singapore special recognition in their want to progress with greater sporting achievements. Joseph Schooling's Olympic win, allows more to dream big.
    • Uncle salutes to Michelle Sng for her best effort for the Nation with this interview of her painful and also exiting moments when she took up High Jump for Woman because of her passion of "why not?" (info: https://mothership.sg/2018/01/michelle-sng/) A prodigy (she says she is not), a performance High Jumper (she says is unexpected), "no pain no gain" and with tears - she had to go through as her journey - making a come-back, an unwilling Champion (humbly just do my best), and she did it for the Nation because there was no representative for the sports she loved and she has passion about it because she participated as a school-girl - just for the sure fun of it. Thank you, Michelle. You are always the most inspired High Jumper (Gold) and aptly the high jump mama...a respect and inspiration for all here. We wish you the best in everything your heart desire.  What's next - SA: a SA-ga-ble NSA.
    • You are right! It is already very good timing. I can't even dream of that!  
    • Why is the Authority (whoever the Stakeholders) are so hype about "Platinum" label aka WMM. Cities/Countries which are ready for "Gold" label upgrading to "Platimum" aka WMM (Selection)   Closer to us, Asia: Tokyo Marathon 2020, Major WMM, Host of Olympics 2020 a selected trial for WMM World Championship. Runners can qualify for the 2020 race by nailing the following times, broken down by age group: 18 to 34 years old (3:00 for men, 3:30 for women) 35 to 39 (3:05 for men, 3:35 for women) 1) Marathon: 7 hours; Wheelchair Marathon: 2 hours and 10 minutes.2) 10km Race: 1 hour and 40 minutes; Wheelchair 10km race: 35 minutes.* The time limits are based on the gun time.* The cut-off time will be enforced at each checkpoint due to reasons of traffic control, security, and event operation.* Runners who fail to pass through the checkpoint before the cut-off time will be disqualified from the race. Furthermore, runners who lag excessively behind the cut-off time pace may be stopped to leave the course at anytime. Maximum Paricipation: 37,000 (Marathon - both HM and FM) So wonder why, "Evening Run will actually attract More" Participation and Qualifiers. When we are "selected as trial", hopefully from 2020, 2021 cut-off time naturally will 7 hours or less "to finalise the trial" to entry WMM Collaborative effort of the Authority with the Nation must be part of this effort as shown by the Government of Spain. That will be missing communication in 2019 SCSM. "Simi sai is WMM?" "How would a sai tang run WMM benefit the Public?" "Why the ultra-national level of Road Closure is beyond the F1 Night Race and NDP?" "Who is that Authority that Grant the Permission?" Leave the matter to the Authority to settle to the Public. As a run community which provides the forum is to info, listen, seek levels to fill the gaps of what is and what is not (fake news); Advise to running partners (newbies or those who have passion to run to live ACTIVE and to compete safely that includes injury management issues - "no pain no gain" is never advocated); Advice on "Race Routes" by race organisers (quality vs non-compliance; sanctioned competitive vs recreational/grassroots), example, Sundown Marathon, offered "previous" routes, hydration and nutrition issues, who's who in the race organiser profile; Pricing;  Greater Earth Sustainability, Education (Injury Management, Nutrition and Hydration, Running Gears, Training and Race Strategy).  Invite previous forummers  (founders) who once "created" SgRunner forum from 2005/7 to 2010 to be such active running communities. Notice from "Guest List", they are viewing events as well as chats of the past, which uncle fondly remembered, "Woodcutter Trial Run" was one of the past events which uncle took almost 1/3 of Forum Thread (as usual - silly chat) to explore and hilarious encounters of wild animals and "ghostly" encounters.  PM and invite them to share, and just say Hi (1 post). Some of these previous forummers posted like more than 10,000 to 15,000, meaning they had contributed for at least a decade worth of knowledge and experience. Please, join us also. Thank you. Uncle ends with this motivational reason why the Authority wants us to believe in WMM is the better way to upgrade the status of running for passion with this challenge : (marketing hype - of course lah) For those who are able, Go for IT! Yes, bring your national flag along. You deserved it!     
    • Central to the topic of interest: Road Closure and Who is the Authority (Decision)?         What is expected in Road Closure for Event?           What is important in IAAF Road Race Label Rules for Road Closure.       SCSM is driving towards the "Platinum" label as entry for WMM in 2021. fyi, when you sign up for run race, previous experiences of "route" from sgRunners' feedback is important. Running on walking path is never "encouraged", unless this is a recreational run especially at PCN Connectors. Expect that Routes sharing with Bikes and PMDs will have a set of rules from 2020. Yes, Bikers and PMDs can also complain about Runners about their entitlements. 
×
×
  • Create New...